Reloader's Nest Forum
Reloader's Nest Forum
Home | Profile | Active Topics | Members | Private Messages | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Reloading General
 General forum
 New S&W 686 .357 magnum
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 2

Csparks1106
Senior Member

USA
340 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  00:35:27  Show Profile Send Csparks1106 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Brought home a new revolver tonight. This one is a 7 round model, I think the Plus model??? Didn't get home until 10:15 tonight so all I got to do was clean it and read the manual. I have a box of 357 rounds I made up years ago for my wife's uncle who never got them. They are loaded with 4.8 grains of IMR SR7625 if memory serves. Lee cast 158 grain SWC. Looking forward to getting a chance to shoot it. It will be awhile until I get any free time but I hope it shoots as well as I've read. Who out there has or has had one and what are your thoughts?

ethmoid1999
Advanced Member



USA
4405 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  07:50:34  Show Profile Send ethmoid1999 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I have two six-shot ones. A four and a six. I love them. I wore out a Python at about 6-7000 rounds. Both of the 686's have round counts around 20,000 and still are tight. I came to prefer the four inch as it balanced better than the six. Both are very accurate. You'll love the 686.
Go to Top of Page

Csparks1106
Senior Member

USA
340 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  09:32:36  Show Profile Send Csparks1106 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
What do you typically shoot out of it? Cast or jacketed?
Go to Top of Page

Kosh75287
Advanced Member



USA
809 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  13:20:42  Show Profile Send Kosh75287 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I'll be looking forward to your report on how your new revolver shoots!

God bless Jeff Cooper

Carpe SCOTCH!
Go to Top of Page

ethmoid1999
Advanced Member



USA
4405 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  17:07:42  Show Profile Send ethmoid1999 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I shoot only 158 grain cast. Medium load of 2400 powder and magnum primer. Mine chronographed around 1100 fps. Haven't got to shoot in a long time. First few cleanings I used a brush and a patch with fine polishing compound from Brownell's. After the burrs were gone, very little leading at all. Both had some burr's when I first shot them. They are fine revolvers.
Go to Top of Page

K22
Senior Member

448 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  19:21:05  Show Profile Send K22 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I have two, both 6", a 686 and a 586 (blue version). These are outstanding, durable and reliable pistols. I have several thousand rounds through mine.

My favorite bullet is Oregan Trail Laser Cast, 125 grain flat point behind 231 Powder, in a 38 special case. Recoil is mild, accuracy is excellent.

For more serious uses, I like the Hornady 125 XTP Hollow Point with 231 Powder in a 357 magnum case.

Go to Top of Page

Kosh75287
Advanced Member



USA
809 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  20:56:37  Show Profile Send Kosh75287 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Not to tell you how to reload, K22, but have you considered using a slower-burning propellant in the 6" barreled revolver? I like WW231 for a number of things, but it seems short-legged for .357-level loads in longer barrels. You might find that Alliant Herco or Power Pistol might give you more velocity, especially, with projectiles heavier than 125gr. Admittedly, neither of the powders I suggest will burn quite as cleanly as WW231, but the "dirty-burning" reputations of each are undeserved, especially at higher-end loads.

There's also 2400, which was used to develop the cartridge, and which I cannot get to burn completely in a 6"-barreled ANYTHING.

God bless Jeff Cooper

Carpe SCOTCH!

Edited by - Kosh75287 on Sep 07 2017 22:34:36
Go to Top of Page

budlight
Advanced Member



USA
1659 Posts

Posted - Sep 07 2017 :  21:41:46  Show Profile Send budlight a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Any quality 357 is a great pistol I have the ruger black Hawk single action 4 5/8ths barrel I think. I buy the Raineer copper plated bullets by the thousands in 125 and 158 grain.

They don't have the velocity restriction like cast or cheap Berry bullets.

I use the slower powders and burn between 9 and 18 grains of powder using the small magnum primers depending if I'm shooting the 38 special brass at +P loads or the 357 brass

38 SP brass is cheap when you buy the 500 once fired online. Shastaboat gave me probably 500 range brass once.

http://www.rainierballistics.com/products-leadsafe-copper-jacket-bullet/
Go to Top of Page

K22
Senior Member

448 Posts

Posted - Sep 08 2017 :  21:16:49  Show Profile Send K22 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Kosh75287

Not to tell you how to reload, K22, but have you considered using a slower-burning propellant in the 6" barreled revolver? I like WW231 for a number of things, but it seems short-legged for .357-level loads in longer barrels. You might find that Alliant Herco or Power Pistol might give you more velocity, especially, with projectiles heavier than 125gr. Admittedly, neither of the powders I suggest will burn quite as cleanly as WW231, but the "dirty-burning" reputations of each are undeserved, especially at higher-end loads.

There's also 2400, which was used to develop the cartridge, and which I cannot get to burn completely in a 6"-barreled ANYTHING.



Yes, I used 2400 for many years and it's the go to powder for full power 357 magnum loads. In my younger days when I was a much better shot with a pistol than I am now I hunted exclusively with a revolver. I took a five point buck, several does, a few foxes, and a bunch of ground hogs with a S&W Model 27, 357 magnum, 8 3/8" barrel.

In those days I used the 140 grain Speer behind a max charge of 2400; an extremely accurate and effective combo. I enjoyed stalk hunting with a pistol; it was a lot of fun and I got fairly good at it. I kept all my game shooting at 50 yards and under which was possible in the deep woods and rolling hills of western PA. I was a discipline of Jeff Cooper's handgun hunting faternity but I couldn't get S&W 44 magnum in those days after the movie Dirty Harry; they just weren't available in my area at any price.

These days I hunt exclusivly with a rifle. My pistol shooting is confined to target practice. In my revolvers, 231 with 125 grain bullets is very accurate, mild to shoot, i.e. fun. I don't have a need for full powder loads in a pistol. In addition I get about 1,200 reloads from a can of 231 powder. If I need a more serious load I can up the 231 powder charge in a 357 case with Hornady 125 XTP bullets but I do most of my shooting with mild charges of 231 in 38 special cases and lead cast bullets.
Go to Top of Page

Csparks1106
Senior Member

USA
340 Posts

Posted - Sep 08 2017 :  22:22:36  Show Profile Send Csparks1106 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I have a can of 2400 that I got because Shasta recommended I use in my 300 Savage with cast bullets. I was planning on using it for these as well. Just picked up a brick of CCI 550 magnum primers. I need to get some brass though. I have maybe 150 pieces including a 1/2 box already loaded. I've got gobs of 38 special brass to play with. And lots of 158 grain swc's, round nose and 148 grain wad cutters.
Go to Top of Page

Shastaboat
Advanced Member



USA
9148 Posts

Posted - Sep 08 2017 :  23:11:31  Show Profile Send Shastaboat a Private Message  Reply with Quote
15 gr of 2400 and 158 gr SWC is a great .357 mag load.
Go to Top of Page

Kosh75287
Advanced Member



USA
809 Posts

Posted - Sep 09 2017 :  18:08:14  Show Profile Send Kosh75287 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Yup, every time a "Dirty Harry" movie came out, UP went the price on ANY N-Frame S&W, but especially the M29s. I used to laugh/cry at the "hotdog" mentalities who'd come in and purchase a model 29, run a box & a half of ammo through it, and then want to trade it for something they could actually shoot well.

All that noise was one reason I gravitated toward .45 Colt revolvers. Their prices tended not to fluctuate much. Proper loading in a revolver built to take the extra pressure of hotter loads yielded a combination that could do anything a 6 1/2" M29 could do, except display the M29's "cool" factor.

God bless Jeff Cooper

Carpe SCOTCH!
Go to Top of Page

K22
Senior Member

448 Posts

Posted - Sep 09 2017 :  23:46:21  Show Profile Send K22 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Kosh75287

Yup, every time a "Dirty Harry" movie came out, UP went the price on ANY N-Frame S&W, but especially the M29s. I used to laugh/cry at the "hotdog" mentalities who'd come in and purchase a model 29, run a box & a half of ammo through it, and then want to trade it for something they could actually shoot well.

All that noise was one reason I gravitated toward .45 Colt revolvers. Their prices tended not to fluctuate much. Proper loading in a revolver built to take the extra pressure of hotter loads yielded a combination that could do anything a 6 1/2" M29 could do, except display the M29's "cool" factor.




At the time I wanted a Model 29 but couldn't find one so I settled for Model 27 (N frame 357). It had an 8 3/8" barrel. It was a great hunting pistol. I found the 357 magnum perfectly adequate for my needs. When the "L" frames hit the market I bought one and it shoots terrific. I later got a stainless version. The heavy rib underneath is a great aid in taming the recoil of a full power load although it makes carry it a little cumbersome.

I also have a Model 19 in 4" barrel for personal carry. Another great S&W.

But my all time favorite pistol is the S&W Model 17, K frame, 22 in 6" barrel. I've done just about everything with this pistol from small game hunting, bullseye competition where I qualified as a distinguish expert and hunter's pistol silouette competition. Mine was acquired in 1970 while I was in the Army and it still shoots terrific 47 years later after thousands of round put through it.
Go to Top of Page

Kosh75287
Advanced Member



USA
809 Posts

Posted - Sep 10 2017 :  01:45:51  Show Profile Send Kosh75287 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
If I need a more serious load I can up the 231 powder charge in a 357 case with Hornady 125 XTP bullets but I do most of my shooting with mild charges of 231 in 38 special cases and lead cast bullets.

Point made. I agree that the mild loads in .38 Spl cases makes for a more enjoyable day of shooting. I like to run SOME heavy loads through mine anytime I shoot it, to keep my hand in, should I ever need to use it for keeps.

I'll bet you can do some REALLY nice longer-range shooting with an 8 3/8" barreled M27! I helped a friend try to wear out a 5" M27 through high school & college, but never made a dent. It was a superb performer, even with the shorter barrel.

God bless Jeff Cooper

Carpe SCOTCH!
Go to Top of Page

Csparks1106
Senior Member

USA
340 Posts

Posted - Sep 16 2017 :  15:15:53  Show Profile Send Csparks1106 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Shastaboat

15 gr of 2400 and 158 gr SWC is a great .357 mag load.



I loaded up some of these last night. What a difference compared to the 38 special with 3.7 grains of SR 7625. You can tell when I switched to the 357 load. Accuracy was great. My kids were busting clays at 25 yards pretty easily. They were shooting the 38 loads. My 19 year old daughter did shoot the 357 load a few times but I decided my 12 year old son didn't need to. I was afraid he would have dropped the gun.

Created: 09/16/17 11:25 AM
Description:
Notes 1:
Notes 2:
Distance to Chrono(FT): 8.00
Ballistic Coefficient: 0.303
Bullet Weight(gr): 185.00
Temp: 90 °F
BP: 30.04 inHg
Altitude: 0.00
# FPS FT-LBS PF
22 1398 802.97 258.63
21 1477 896.29 273.24
20 1450 863.82 268.25
19 1410 816.82 260.85
18 1429 838.98 264.36
17 1427 836.63 263.99
16 1397 801.83 258.45
15 1451 865.01 268.43
14 ERROR 3
13 781 250.60 144.49
12 829 282.36 153.37
11 840 289.90 155.40
10 768 242.33 142.08
9 788 255.12 145.78
8 731 219.54 135.24
7 795 259.67 147.07
6 853 298.94 157.80
5 780 249.96 144.30
4 795 259.67 147.07
3 832 284.40 153.92
2 764 239.81 141.34
1 803 264.92 148.55
Average: 1038.0 FPS
SD: 316.6 FPS
Min: 731 FPS
Max: 1477 FPS
Spread: 746 FPS
Shot/sec: 0.0
True MV: 1040 FPS


Go to Top of Page

Shastaboat
Advanced Member



USA
9148 Posts

Posted - Sep 16 2017 :  18:52:18  Show Profile Send Shastaboat a Private Message  Reply with Quote
So did you load 15 gr of 2400 with a 185 gr bullet? Welcome to Magnum Pistol rounds.
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 2 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic  Reply to Topic
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Reloader's Nest Forum © 2016 ReloadersNest Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.25 seconds. Powered By: Snitz Forums 2000 Version 3.4.06